Blog   |   Pakistan

After Malala shooting, Taliban goes after media critics

Pakistani children in Karachi pray for the recovery of 14-year-old schoolgirl Malala Yousafzai, who was shot by the Taliban, on October 12. (AP/Shakil Adil)

Journalists, like many others in Pakistan, have spoken out strongly since the Taliban attempted to kill the teenage Malala Yousafzai on October 9. The Taliban, in return, are threatening the media over their coverage, according to journalists and news reports.

"Media houses, tv anchors and some well-known journalists are under serious threat," one of our colleagues messaged. "I understand that some intelligence reports had also intercepted telephone calls to them. The threats are coming in Swat, Peshawar, Islamabad, Lahore, and Karachi. The situation got worst after media coverage of Malala Yousafzai's case which made the extremists quite angry."

On The New Yorker website, Ahmed Rashid, who is on CPJ's board of directors and is no stranger to threat, wrote from Lahore, "Can Malala Bring Peace to Pakistan and Afghanistan?" Rashid calls on the government to crack down on extremists "in the tribal territories of North and South Waziristan to wipe out the ever growing networks of extremists, including Mullah Fazlullah, who is believed to be the mastermind of the attempted murder of Malala."

From a far different part of Pakistan's media spectrum comes Hamid Mir, the popular, controversial television anchor for Geo TV and a widely read columnist. Mir sent along a copy of a seven-page open letter from Pakistani Taliban spokesman Ehsanullah Ehsan; Mir was concerned because his name is mentioned about five times, and he is accused of being "un-Islamic. "

The message offers up a justification for the killing of Malala, who the Taliban consider to be an adult (She has been variously reported as 14 or 15 years old). The group wrote that women who abide by sharia are not supposed to be killed, but it is permitted, even dutiful, to kill those who aren't as virtuous. The statement singles out the role of Malala, who had blogged for the BBC, in supposedly spreading propaganda against Muslims.

"This is the second email from the Taliban in 24 hours. They are freely using emails, calling our colleagues on their mobile phones and the government is doing nothing except telling us 'The Taliban will kill you,'" Mir said by email.  He was referring to official notices sent to journalists by local police that they "are on the hit list of the [Pakistani] Taliban to be targeted," and offering police protection.  None of the journalists we contacted who had received such notices wanted us to use their names-- understandable given the increased level of threat they are facing. But local journalists and news reports did say that the Interior Ministry has increased security near media organizations.

Many Pakistani reporters tell us of having to deal with a constant fear of retaliation if any of the many sides to the conflict in Pakistan should be unhappy with their reporting. And the Taliban, in some cases, have claimed responsibility for killing journalists. But while not media friendly, the Taliban have become very media savvy, making full use of the Internet and other digital platforms and keeping local and international journalists on their speed dial to make sure they are heard.

CPJ has written widely about threats to journalists, and has encouraged media personnel to tell their employers and colleagues and actually report on the threats they receive; we feel it is the best way to counter those threats. The widely spread revelations about the latest round, this time from Taliban groups, is an indicator of how successful that tactic can be.  It takes a great deal of courage, because in Pakistan, threats cannot be taken idly. In 2010 and 2011, more journalists were killed in Pakistan than in any other country. And many of those who died in targeted killings had first been warned to be silent.

Journalist Hayatullah Khan, for example, was threatened by virtually every regional faction: Pakistan's intelligence service, the military, the Taliban, and al-Qaeda. In 2006, Khan was abducted and killed. The day before, Khan had filed a story and photographs indicating that a U.S.-made missile had struck a home in the tribal town of Miran Shah, killing senior al-Qaeda operative Hamza Rabia. The pictures--widely distributed by the European Pressphoto Agency --contradicted the Pakistani government's explanation that Rabia had died in a blast caused by explosives in the house. To date, the government has refused to release an investigative report into his killing despite demands by civil society.

In fact, while the Pakistani authorities have arrested several suspects in Malala's case, the same government has not demonstrated a willingness to investigate the scores of attacks on journalists. Pakistan ranks tenth in CPJ's impunity index, which calculates unsolved journalist murders as a percentage of each country's population. Pakistan's rating worsened for the fourth straight year, and several unsolved journalist murders have suspected government links.

Some journalists have extrapolated the attack on Malala to make deeper calls for change in Pakistan. In Islamabad's The News, columnist Talat Farooqi captured the stunned state of many Pakistanis, asking if Malala is a mirror of a political system that has led its country off the tracks:

And just when one's defense mechanism had kicked in and one could hear about (other) people dying in terror attacks without losing one's sleep, Malala decided to shake us to the core of our beings. Malala is the mirror in which we can all see our faces and what ugly faces we have!

Take a good look--here are the Taliban, here are the Taliban supporters, here are the politicians and here are we, the common men and women of Pakistan. The Taliban are gleeful, the Taliban supporters, bearded or clean-shaven, are cautious; the politicians are alert, wondering how to manipulate the situation; and we, the common men and women of Pakistan are shocked, as if what has happened is a bolt from the blue.

As if innocent men, women and children are not being killed and maimed day in and day out in this land of the pure for the last 11 years. All of us are guilty. Malala is a mirror and this is what she reminds us of.

Like this article? Support our work

Comments

young women of pakistan should form groups and grab taliban members and castrate them--then they would be more docile. Even more, it would put fear in their minds and they would not harm women. Lets have a women's revolt. No more shooting children. Let's see how brave the Taliban is without their testicles.

Plz ask taliban not more shoot the children of any one

It would be interesting if a translation of the Taliban letter (so far, I've only come across urdu versions) would be available so that people could actually read what justification the Taliban used and once and for all dismiss them as the lunatics they really are... Do you know where one can find it?

November 10 is dedicated to Malala.....Taliban must be ashamed of themselves