|
JANUARY 10, 2003
Iden Wetherell, The Independent
Vincent Kahiya, The Independent
Dumisani Muleya, The Independent
HARASSED, LEGAL ACTION
Wetherell, managing editor of the Harare-based independent weekly The
Independent, News Editor Kahiya, and reporter Muleya, were arrested
following the publication of a story in the January 9 edition of The
Independent co-authored by Muleya alleging that Zimbabwean President
Robert Mugabe had commandeered an Air Zimbabwe plane for his trip to East
Asia, thereby stranding passengers who were slated to fly on the plane
between Harare and London. The piece also quoted a source saying that
the plane carried containers for storage of goods Mugabe might acquire
on his trip.
Muleya said that during interrogation by police, he was asked to reveal
the story's sources but refused. The three journalists were charged with
criminal defamation. On Monday, January 12, they were released on 20,000
Zimbabwean Dollars (US$25) bail each after appearing in court. Their next
court hearing is scheduled for January 29.
Itai Dzamara, a reporter with the weekly who co-authored the piece with
Muleya, and the paper's general manager, Raphael Khumalo, were arrested
on January 14 after presenting themselves to police at Harare Central
Police Station. Both were summoned to appear at the station for questioning
in connection with the January 9 report.
Dzamara was charged with criminal defamation before being released that
afternoon. Khumalo was released the same day without charge. Dzamara will
likely appear with three other Independent journalists in court
on January 29.
Information Minister Jonathan Moyo described the report as "blasphemous,"
saying it was a "deliberate falsehood calculated to bring the office of
the president into disrepute," the BBC reported.
Meanwhile, on January 13, the state-owned daily The Herald published
an open letter from Media and Information Commission (MIC) head Tafataona
Mahoso to Wetherell accusing The Independent of racism for publishing
a letter to the editor claiming that Zimbabweans are stupid and comparing
them to wild animals. Mahoso concluded the letter by writing, "All publishers
and editors in Zimbabwe should consider this MIC statement as a warning
to them as well and not just to the Zimbabwe Independent."
The Independent editor disputed the claim that the column's remarks
were racist, saying the letter was a legitimate part of the national discourse
on the country's political and economic crisis. Wetherell said he believes
that the MIC could use the racism charge as a pretext to deny registration
to the publication or accreditation to its journalists.
JANUARY 28, 2003
Tsvangirayi Mukawazhi, Daily News, The Associated Press
Dina Kraft, The Associated Press
Jason Beaubien, National Public Radio
HARASSED
Mukawazhi, chief photographer for the independent Daily News and
a freelancer for The Associated Press (AP); Kraft, a Johannesburg-based
journalist for the AP; and Beaubien, a Johannesburg-based correspondent
for National Public Radio, were arrested by Zimbabwean police after visiting
the Grain Marketing Board's (GMB) depot, a food distribution center in
Bulawayo. Charles Mpofu, an opposition Movement for Democratic Change
councilor in Bulawayo who was guiding the journalists around the city,
was also detained, the Daily News reported.
The journalists were accused of unlawful entry and of taking photographs
in a restricted security area. They were told that they were not permitted
to take photographs of the silos containing maize grain, Beaubien said
in an interview with Agence France-Presse.
Kraft and Beaubien had been issued temporary accreditation to practice
journalism in Zimbabwe. They said that depot security guards had allowed
the journalists into the GMB site. The journalists were detained for seven
hours and questioned. They were released after police photocopied their
notebooks and passports.
FEBRUARY 19, 2003
Philimon Bulawayo, Daily News
HARASSED
Bulawayo, a photographer for the independent Daily News, was assaulted
by soldiers monitoring lines at a supermarket in the capital, Harare.
Bulawayo was preparing to take pictures of the long lines of people waiting
to collect food when two soldiers approached him and began to manhandle
him.
The soldiers handed Bulawayo over to nearby police, who handcuffed the
photographer and took him to the local police station. Officers beat the
journalist, seized his camera, and exposed his film. Police then took
down the journalist's personal information and warned him not to visit
any other places where people would be waiting for food. When contacted
by CPJ, Daily News staffers said Bulawayo's injuries were not severe.
MARCH 18, 2003
Philimon Bulawayo, Daily News
IMPRISONED, ATTACKED
Bulawayo, a photographer for the private Daily News, was arrested
in the morning by police while covering a demonstration in a suburb of
the capital, Harare. He was taken to Glen View Police Station and held
without charge, and police severely beat him in his cell.
At around noon the same day, Gugulethu Moyo, legal adviser and corporate
affairs director for the Associated Newspapers of Zimbabwe (ANZ), which
publishes the Daily News, went to the station to try to secure
Bulawayo's release. Moyo was assaulted outside the building by Jocelyn
Chiwenga, the wife of army officer Lt. Gen. Constantine Chiwenga, and
then arrested by police.
Sources at the Daily News said they did not know what prompted
Chiwenga to attack Moyo. But in a first-person account of the incident
published later in the newspaper, Moyo said that Chiwenga was infuriated
when she learned that he worked for the ANZ and accused the compnay of
promoting British interests and publishing lies about Zimbabwe.
Police denied both Bulawayo and Moyo medical treatment for their injuries
and later transferred them to Harare Central Police Station. The two men
were freed without charge on March 20 following a High Court order for
their release. They were immediately taken to the hospital for treatment.
Daily News journalists say that Bulawayo and Moyo have had trouble
walking since they were assaulted.
MARCH 19 2003
Stanley Karombo, freelance
IMPRISONED, LEGAL ACTION
Karombo, a Zimbabwean freelance journalist, was arrested in the eastern
town of Mutare and charged with "practicing journalism without a license"
under the Access to Information and Protection of Privacy Act (AIPPA).
Karombo had gone to the local police station with a colleague from the
private Daily Mirror who was conducting an interview at the station.
During the interview, Karombo stepped into the station's hallway to receive
a telephone call from SW Radio Africa, an independent, Zimbabwean-run
shortwave radio station based in London, England. Officers overheard Karombo
talking about an antigovernment strike organized by the opposition Movement
for Democratic Change (MDC) on March 18-19. Local sources said Karombo
has filed stories for SW Radio Africa in the past.
Police approached Karomba and began asking why he was talking about the
strike. They then seized his phone and noticed that it had the numbers
of MDC officials in its memory. Police accused Karombo of being an MDC
supporter, arrested him, and took him to his home to search it. When police
found stories that Karombo had filed, they demanded his accreditation
papers, which he did not have.
Karombo was jailed until March 24, when he was released on bail of around
US$6, the local chapter of the Media Institute of Southern Africa reported.
Karombo said that during his detention, he was beaten and denied access
to his lawyer. His trial is pending. On May 20, a Mutare court removed
Karombo from remand pending the outcome of a Supreme Court decision on
a constitutional challenge to the AIPPA, under which he was charged.
MAY 7, 2003
Posted: October 20, 2004
Andrew Meldrum, The Guardian
HARASSED
A group of immigration officers visited the home of Meldrum, Zimbabwe
correspondent for the London-based Guardian newspaper, at about
7:15 p.m. and demanded to speak with the journalist. The men would not
identify themselves or reveal why the journalist needed to be questioned.
Though his wife informed the officers that Meldrum was not home, they
refused to leave.
When Meldrum's lawyer, Beatrice Mtetwa, arrived at the scene shortly thereafter
and questioned the men, they left, promising to return with reinforcements.
Later that night, one of the vehicles that had brought the officers earlier
on stopped in front of Meldrum's house, but no one exited the car.
On May 8, Mtetwa visited the Department of Immigration in the capital,
Harare, to ask about the men's visit. Officials confirmed that they wanted
to speak to Meldrum but would not say why. Mtetwa told CPJ that unidentified
individuals followed her after she left work the same day.
Mtetwa told the immigration department that Meldrum was willing to appear
at the immigration offices during regular daytime hours provided that
proper legal procedure was followed and he was informed as to what the
questioning was about.
MAY 13, 2003
Posted: October 20, 2004
Andrew Meldrum, The Guardian
HARASSED, EXPELLED
Meldrum, Zimbabwe correspondent for the London-based Guardian newspaper,
attended a meeting at the Department of Immigration during which his passport
and residence permit were confiscated. Officials told him that his permit
only allowed him to report on economics and tourism. Meldrum had recently
filed stories about the deteriorating political and economic climate in
Zimbabwe and police brutality. But Meldrum told CPJ that his residence
permit does not include any conditions on his reporting.
On May 16, Meldrum returned to the Department of Immigration at 10:00
a.m. for a scheduled meeting with officials, where he was informed he
had to leave the country. The deportation order, signed by Home Affairs
Minister Kembo Mahadi, called Meldrum "an undesirable inhabitant" of Zimbabwe
but said it was not in the public interest to disclose why, The Associated
Press reported.
Immediately after the meeting, while he was speaking to journalists outside
the immigration offices, police manhandled Meldrum, pushed him into an
unmarked car, and drove him directly to the Harare Airport, local sources
told CPJ.
The same day, Mtetwa obtained a High Court stay against the journalist's
deportation and presented it to officials at the airport. The court ordered
that Meldrum be allowed to attend a hearing on his deportation on that
day. However, officials did not produce the journalist.
According to the Guardian, in the evening, immigration officers
at the airport ran away from Mtetwa to avoid being served with a second
court order demanding Meldrum's immediate release and forbidding his deportation.
Meldrum was barred contact with anyone while he was in custody at the
airport.
Officials at Harare Airport later forced Meldrum onto a London-bound Air
Zimbabwe flight, ignoring the High Court orders staying the reporter's
deportation and instructing authorities to produce Meldrum for a court
hearing on his expulsion. He arrived in London the next day.
Mtetwa is currently fighting a court battle to have Meldrum returned to
the country at the state's expense, and to see that Immigration Department
officials are charged for violating the court orders.
On June 11, Dolores Cortes Meldrum, Andrew's wife, fled the country after
being summoned to the Immigration Department. Cortes Meldrum had recently
had her residency permit revoked despite the fact that her permit had
been issued to her independently of her husband. Mtetwa, also serving
as her lawyer, said that Cortes Meldrum decided to flee the country for
fear of being forcibly deported like her husband.
JUNE 2, 2003
Shorai Katiwa, Voice of the People
Martin Chimenya, Voice of the People
HARASSED
Voice of the People
CENSORED
Katiwa and Chimenya, journalists for Voice of the People (VOP), a private
news production company, were assaulted by supporters of the ruling ZANU-PF
party while covering student protests during a week of demonstrations
sponsored by the opposition Movement for Democratic Change (MDC). The
journalists approached a group of men on the street who they thought were
students. They turned out to be ZANU-PF supporters who immediately detained
the reporters and began to search them. When the ZANU-PF supporters found
the business cards of opposition MPs in the journalists' wallets, the
men accused Katiwa and Chimenya of supporting the protests, then beat
them and confiscated their mobile phones and minidisk recorders.
Zimbabwean sources said Katiwa and Chimenya were taken to a local police
station and then to ZANU-PF headquarters, where they were further assaulted.
Police, who were called by the ruling-party supporters, later forced the
journalists to take them to the home of VOP coordinator John Masuku and
seized administrative files and the computer the journalists use to file
their stories. The next day, the computer and files were returned to the
journalists. Katiwa's and Chimenya's phones and recorders were not returned.
JUNE 6, 2003
Spicer Productions
HARASSED
Police raided the offices and home of Edwina and Newton Spicer, of Spicer
Productions, an independent documentary production company. Though the
officers did not have a warrant, they seized equipment belonging to the
production company and attacked several employees. The Spicers were out
of the country on vacation at the time of the raid.
On June 9, police returned to the Spicers' offices and home, this time
bearing a warrant allowing them to search for "subversive materials."
Police seized video cameras and tapes. Sources in the capital, Harare,
said police conducted themselves professionally on this occasion and that
no employees were harassed.
The Spicers have produced numerous documentaries about Zimbabwe and the
ongoing political and economic crisis in the country. Journalists in Harare
said the police might have raided the Spicers' offices because they suspect
the production company of providing recent news footage of the violent
suppression of mass protests to international broadcasters.
AUGUST 8, 2003
Flata Kavinga, The Midlands Observer
ATTACKED
A group of young men brutally assaulted Kavinga, a reporter for the English-language
weekly The Midlands Observer. According to local sources, six menat
least two of them members of the ruling ZANU-PF partyapproached
the reporter outside a nightclub in Kwekwe, a city in the central part
of the country. The men accused The Midlands Observer of supporting
the opposition Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) and said that Kavinga
must be pro-MDC because his T-shirt bore the logo of the Media Institute
of Southern Africa (MISA) and read: "Free my voiceFree the airways."
After dragging Kavinga into an alley behind the club, the assailants attacked
the journalist, beating him with planks of wood and injuring his head
and body. Kavinga's friends later brought him to a hospital. The journalist's
colleagues told CPJ that he went into hiding after the assault in order
to avoid further reprisal.
SEPTEMBER 12, 2003
Updated: October 20, 2004
Daily News
CENSORED
Zimbabwean authorities shuttered the offices of the Harare-based Daily
News, the country's only independent daily.
In the evening, around 20 police officers entered the building that houses
the Daily News' offices and ordered the paper's staff to leave.
Police detained three staff members, including the circulation manager,
and editor Nqobile Nyathi was told to report to Harare's main police station,
Agence France-Presse reported.
The newspaper's closure followed a September 11 Supreme Court declaration
that the Daily News was operating illegally under provisions of
the repressive Access to Information and Protection of Privacy Act (AIPPA).
Under AIPPA, all media companies are required to register with the Media
and Information Commission (MIC), created by the act, in order to operate.
Individual journalists must also be accredited by the MIC to practice.
The minister of communications appoints the commission's board in consultation
with the president.
The registration application for media companies forces them to disclose
details such as their business plans and the curricula vitae and political
affiliations of their directors, Zimbabwean journalists said.
Rather than registering with the MIC, the Associated Newspapers of Zimbabwe
(ANZ), the company that owns the Daily News, challenged the legislation
as unconstitutional.
On September 11, Supreme Court Chief Justice Godfrey Chidyausiku said
that because ANZ had not registered with the commission, it was "operating
outside the law," and that the court would only hear the company's constitutional
challenge once it had "submitted itself to the law" by registering.
On September 15, the Daily News filed an application to register
with the commission and also sought an urgent ruling from the High Court
permitting the paper to continue publishing while its application was
being considered. According to the newspaper's legal adviser and ANZ corporate
affairs director, Gugulethu Moyo, the application procedure under AIPPA
stipulates that media institutions should be allowed to continue operations
while approval of their registration is pending. Authorities disputed
this claim, local sources told CPJ, saying the provision only held for
the transition period of registration, which ended on December 31, 2002.
Moreover, Information Minister Jonathan Moyo (no relation to Gugulethu
Moyo) told state television that the Daily News' application for
registration was incomplete. Sources at the paper said they were informed
that they had failed to include a code of ethics with the application.
On September 16, detectives, security agents, armed paramilitary members,
and riot police raided the Daily News' offices and seized computers
and other equipment belonging to the newspaper.
Gugulethu Moyo said that police produced no warrant or court order authorizing
the seizure and argued that police were pre-empting the law since the
newspaper had not been convicted of any offense.
On September 17, police arrested about 100 pro-democracy activists who
had demonstrated in the streets of Harare to protest the government's
crackdown on the Daily News and the country's worsening political
and economic situation.
On September 18, Zimbabwe's High Court ruled to allow the Daily News
to resume publishing after being closed for seven days. A High Court judge
also ordered authorities to immediately return computers and other equipment
confiscated by the police during the September 16 raid.
The Daily News had asked the High Court to rule that the seizure
of its equipment was illegal. Attorneys for the newspaper also argued
that the Daily News was entitled under media laws to reopen until
its registration application with the state media commission is completed.
Journalists at the Daily News said that immediately after the ruling,
they returned to their offices and began work on a new edition for the
following day. However, in the evening, police again occupied the offices
and prevented the journalists from working. The move defied the High Court
ruling allowing the newspaper to reopen and directing police to return
confiscated equipment. The government appealed the High Court ruling on
September 19.
Also on September 19, in a unanimous board decision, the MIC rejected
the Daily News' application for registration. According to the
state-owned Herald, the MIC argued that ANZ could not be registered
because it had been publishing illegally for eight-and-a-half months (since
the end of the transitional period-December 31, 2002). The MIC referred
to the September 11 Supreme Court declaration, which said that the company
need not have submitted a registration application in order to comply
with the law; it only had to stop publishing while its constitutional
challenge was pending.
The MIC said that the ANZ had illegally employed unaccredited journalists,
though journalists at the Daily News said they were refused accreditation
on the grounds that they were working for an unregistered publication.
The MIC said further that the ANZ had failed to provide the commission
with a free copy of every edition of its papers, as is required under
AIPPA.
The ANZ appealed the MIC decision and on October 2 was granted an urgent
hearing scheduled for October 16. According to the Zimbabwe chapter of
the Media Institute of Southern Africa, the company is arguing that the
MIC's decisions are null and void because the commission's members were
not properly nominated. Section 40 of AIPPA stipulates that an association
of journalists or media houses must nominate at least three of the MIC's
board members, but none of the commission's current board members were
so nominated.
On October 1, however, a High Court judge had denied an ANZ application
seeking the return of equipment seized from the Daily News' offices
by police.
Meanwhile, on September 25, police began summoning and charging Daily
News journalists who appear on a list of 45 journalists working for
the paper that the ANZ had submitted to the MIC along with its registration
application. The journalists are being charged with violating Section
83 of AIPPA by practicing journalism without accreditation.
Sources at the Daily News said the newspaper is losing about 38
million Zimbabwe dollars (US$46,000) each day it does not publish.
On September 22, four ANZ directors-ANZ CEO Samuel Sipepa Nkomo, Michael
Stuart Mattinson, Brian Mutsau, and Rachel Kuapara-were arrested and charged
with violating the AIPPA. They were released later that day.
According to the state-owned Herald newspaper, if convicted, the
directors each face a large fine or a two-year jail term.
On October 24, the Harare Administrative Court ruled that the MIC had
been biased in its decision to reject the ANZ application, and that the
commission was improperly constituted because none of its members was
nominated by an association of journalists or media houses, as stipulated
under the AIPPA. The court directed that a properly constituted commission
grant the ANZ a registration certificate by November 30.
After consulting with lawyers, the Daily News decided to publish
its October 25 edition despite the legal confusion over the status of
their license.
But on October 25, while the newspaper was working on its October 26 edition,
police raided the Daily News offices and arrested 18 journalists.
All the journalists were released later that day after being forced to
sign statements saying they worked for the ANZ.
On October 26 and 27, police arrested five ANZ directors and again charged
them with publishing a newspaper without a license under AIPPA.
On December 19, 2003, an administrative court again ruled that the paper
should be permitted to resume publication. The same day, however, police
occupied the offices of the Daily News and the premises of the
ANZ's printing press. The police refused to allow journalists to enter
the buildings to work.
On January 9, 2004, a High Court judge ordered police to vacate the newspaper's
offices and printing press, but police remained on the premises. On January
21, the High Court again ordered police to vacate the newspaper's offices
and to allow journalists back to work. Police finally left the premises
that day, after the paper's staff served them with the order.
The Daily News resumed publication on January 22. But that day,
the MIC and the Information Ministry both filed applications to the High
Court seeking a stay to the January 21 ruling in order to stop the paper
from publishing, said Daily News legal adviser Gugulethu Moyo.
On February 5, Zimbabwe's Supreme Court upheld AIPPA's licensing and registration
regime. The Independent Journalists Association of Zimbabwe's had mounted
a legal challenge to the legislation on the grounds that the compulsory
registration violated journalists' constitutional right to freedom of
expression.
The Daily News ceased publication on February 6. According to international
news reports, the ANZ directors decided stopped publishing out of fear
that their journalists could be arrested for working without accreditation
following the previous day's Supreme Court ruling.
Brian Mutsau, one of the ANZ's directors, told Agence France-Presse that
the Daily News journalists obtained the necessary forms from the
MIC and would apply for accreditation.
SEPTEMBER 16, 2003
Tsvangirai Mukwazhi, freelance
Paul Cadenhead, Reuters
HARASSED, CENSORED
Mukwazhi, a freelance photographer, and Cadenhead, a photographer working
for Reuters news agency, were arrested and taken to the Harare Central
Police Station for questioning.
The two photographers were arrested at the offices of the Daily News,
Zimbabwe's only independent daily, while they were taking pictures of
a police raid on the premises. The raid followed a September 11 Supreme
Court declaration that the newspaper was operating illegally since it
had failed to register with Zimbabwe's Media and Information Commission.
Sources at the scene said that police were in the process of seizing the
newspaper's equipment when the two photographers were detained, manhandled,
and bundled into police vehicles. Police also confiscated the journalists'
cameras.
The two journalists were released later in the day after being charged
with "conduct likely to provoke a breach of the peace," signing admissions
of guilt under the advice of their lawyer, and paying fines of $5,000
Zimbabwe dollars (US$6) each. Police returned the journalists' cameras,
but Cadenhead said that police forced him to erase five digital photographs
depicting Mukwazhi being manhandled by police. Journalists working for
the state media were allowed unfettered access to cover the police raid,
local sources said.
SEPTEMBER 17, 2003
Posted: September 18, 2003
Tsvangirai Mukwazhi, freelance
Syrus Nhara, freelance
Aaron Ufumeli, freelance
HARASSED
Police arrested freelance journalists Mukwazhi, Nhara, and Ufumeli at
a pro-democracy protest in the capital, Harare. According to news reports,
the protesters were calling for a new constitution and the reopening of
the Daily News, an independent newspaper that was shut down on
September 12.
The journalists were held overnight in a holding cell at the Harare Central
Police Station, and police questioned them about how they knew about the
protest, and whether they were given permission to cover it, according
to Mukwazhi.
The journalists were released after paying a small fine and were charged
with "interfering with police activity," Mukwazhi said. Police also arrested
more than 100 protesters, according to news reports.
SEPTEMBER 25, 2003
Posted: October 9, 2003
Daily News LEGAL ACTION
Police in Zimbabwe's capital, Harare, charged nine journalists from the
Daily News with violating Section 83 of the Access to Information and Protection
of Privacy Act (AIPPA) by practicing journalism without accreditation.
The journalists, who were summoned to the Harare central police station in the
morning, were on a list of 45 Daily News journalists that the management
of the Associated Newspapers of Zimbabwe (ANZ), the company that owns the paper,
submitted to police earlier in the week in response to a police request.
All nine signed "warned and cautioned" statements before being released,
said journalists in Harare. The state-owned Herald newspaper quoted police
sources saying that they intend to call in the remaining journalists on the list.
Under AIPPA, all Zimbabwean media companies must be registered with
the Media And Information Commission (MIC), and all journalists have to be accredited
by the commission. Journalists at the Daily News, the country's only independent
daily, said that they had applied for accreditation but were refused on the grounds
that they were working for an unregistered publication. Because the ANZ had mounted
a constitutional challenge to AIPPA, the company had not registered the Daily
News with the MIC. The ANZ applied for registration on September 15, 2003,
but their application was denied by the MIC a few days later. Among the grounds
for the rejection of the application was that the ANZ had employed unaccredited
journalists. Daily News legal adviser Gugulethu Moyo said that
the paper's legal team is seeking a stay of prosecution against the charged journalists,
while legal challenges to the act are pending. According to Moyo, the
maximum penalty for the offense of practicing journalism without accreditation
is two years' imprisonment and a fine. On October 1, six more Daily
News journalists were summoned to police headquarters and charged with practicing
journalism without accreditation. Among the journalists charged are:
News Editor Luke Tamborinyoka, Deputy News Editor Pedzisai Ruhanya, former Editor-in-Chief
Francis Mdlongwa, and senior reporters Precious Shumba and Chengetai Zvauya.
OCTOBER 26, 2003
Updated: October 20, 2004
Washington Sansole, ANZ
HARASSED, LEGAL ACTION
Samuel Sipepa Nkomo, ANZ
Michael Stuart Mattinson, ANZ
Brian Mutsau, ANZ
Rachel Kuapara, ANZ
IMPRISONED, LEGAL ACTION
Police in the southwestern city of Bulawayo arrested Sansole, a director
for the Associated Newspapers of Zimbabwe (ANZ), the company that owns
the Daily News, and charged him with publishing a newspaper
without a license. According to Daily News legal adviser Gugulethu
Moyo, authorities told the ANZ that they would not release Sansole until
the ANZ's other directors presented themselves to the police. Sansole
was freed on October 27 after the newspaper's lawyers obtained a High
Court order for his release, Moyo told CPJ.
The four other ANZ directors-CEO Nkomo, Mattinson, Mutsau, and Kuapara-were
arrested on the afternoon of October 27 after presenting themselves to
police in Harare. They were charged with publishing a newspaper without
a license under Zimbabwe's repressive Access to Information and Protection
of Privacy Act (AIPPA).
The four directors were released on October 29 after paying 50,000 Zimbabwe
dollars (US$60) bail each.
Local journalists said that police had arrested Tulepi Nkomo, Sipepa Nkomo's
niece, on October 25 after failing to find the director at his home in
Harare. Tulepi Nkomo was released by police on October 27, after being
charged with "conduct likely to breach the peace" and paying a fine. The
arrests came after the Daily News published on October 25 its first
edition since police closed the newspaper on September 12 following a
Supreme Court declaration that the paper was operating illegally because
it had not registered with the country's Media and Information Commission
(MIC). The ANZ's application to register with the MIC was rejected the
following week.
On October 24, the Harare Administrative Court ruled that the MIC had
been biased in its decision to reject the ANZ application, and that the
commission was improperly constituted because none of its members was
nominated by an association of journalists or media houses, as stipulated
under AIPPA. The court directed that a properly constituted commission
grant the ANZ a registration certificate by November 30. After consulting
with lawyers, the Daily News decided to publish its Saturday edition
despite the legal confusion over the status of the newspaper's license.
But on October 25, as the newspaper was working on its Sunday edition,
police raided the Daily News offices and arrested 18 journalists.
All of the journalists were released later that day, after being made
to sign statements saying they worked for the ANZ.
The ANZ directors had also been arrested in September and likewise charged
after the Daily News published a September 12 edition following
the Supreme Court declaration the previous day.
On September 20, 2004, a magistrate's court in Harare acquitted Nkomo,
Mattinson, Mutsau, and Kupara, who had been charged with publishing the
newspaper illegally. The court ruled that the state had "failed to show
a prima facie case against the accused," according to international news
reports.
Similar charges against ANZ, which owns the Daily News, were also
dismissed, defense lawyer Beatrice Mtetwa told CPJ.
DECEMBER 8, 2003
Posted: February 20, 2004
Martin Chimenya, Voice of the People
IMPRISONED, LEGAL ACTION
Chimenya, a reporter for Voice of the People, an independent radio station
that broadcasts into Zimbabwe from Madagascar using a Radio Netherlands
transmitter, was arrested in Masvingo, a town nearly 186 miles (300 kilometers)
south of the capital, Harare.
Chimenya said that Central Intelligence Organization officers arrested
him at his home and ordered him to take all of his journalistic equipment,
including a tape recorder and tapes, with him. According to the Zimbabwe
chapter of the Media Institute for Southern Africa, which hired a lawyer
to represent Chimenya, the journalist's whereabouts were unknown until
the afternoon of December 9 because police initially denied that he had
been arrested. Chimenya's lawyer was allowed to see him that day at the
Masvingo police station.
Chimenya said the arrest likely came because an informer witnessed him
interviewing Douglas Mwonzora, a spokesperson for the National Constitutional
Association, a pressure group for constitutional reform. During the interview,
Mwonzora spoke about Zimbabwe's recent withdrawal from the Commonwealth
and criticized President Robert Mugabe. Mwonzora was also arrested after
the interview.
On December 10, Chimenya was brought before a court and charged under
Section 79 of the Access to Information and Protection of Privacy Act
for practicing journalism without accreditation. He was released on bail
of 15,000 Zimbabwe Dollars (US$19). His case is pending.
|